Frequently Asked Questions
Absolutely not — a car is a liability in NYC. The subway, buses, ferries, and rideshares cover everything. Parking costs $40-80/day in Manhattan, traffic is brutal, and the congestion pricing toll ($9+) now charges vehicles entering Manhattan below 60th Street. Use the subway and walk. If you are also visiting upstate New York (Adirondacks, Finger Lakes, Hudson Valley), rent a car for the upstate portion only and drop it off before returning to the city.
Yes. The NYC subway carries 3.5+ million riders daily and serious incidents are extremely rare. Standard precautions: stay alert, keep valuables secure, ride in the conductor's car (middle of the train) late at night, and avoid empty cars. The subway runs 24/7, though late-night waits can be 15-20 minutes. Daytime and evening hours are busy and safe. The system has more police presence now than at any time in recent years.
Budget traveler: $150-200/day (hostels, street food, free museums, subway). Mid-range: $300-500/day (3-star hotel, restaurants, attractions, shows). Luxury: $700+/day (boutique hotels, fine dining, premium experiences). A typical 5-day mid-range trip for two costs $3,000-5,000 including accommodation, food, attractions, and local transport (not including flights). NYC is expensive, but dollar pizza, free parks, and museum free-hours help enormously.
January through early March offers the lowest hotel prices — 30-40% below peak season. The weather is cold (25-40F) but manageable with proper layers. Restaurant Week (late January) offers prix-fixe lunch and dinner at top restaurants. Broadway shows are easier to get and TKTS discounts are deeper. Late August and early September (after summer, before fall foliage) is another value window. Avoid Christmas/New Year, Fashion Week (September), and UN General Assembly (late September) for the highest prices.
From JFK: AirTrain + subway ($11.40 total, 60-75 min) is cheapest. LIRR from Jamaica ($8.50 AirTrain + $11 LIRR) is fastest to Penn Station (45 min total). Taxis have a flat $70 rate. From LaGuardia: Q70-SBS bus to 7 train (free transfer, 60 min) or taxi ($35-55). From Newark: AirTrain + NJ Transit ($15.25, 45 min to Penn Station). Uber/Lyft from any airport runs $60-100. Avoid helicopter transfers — not worth the $200+ unless money is no object.
The standard tip in New York restaurants is 20% on the pre-tax total. 18% is acceptable for adequate service; 25% for exceptional service. An easy calculation: double the NYC tax (8.875%) for roughly 18%, or move the decimal and double for 20%. Never tip less than 15% unless the service was genuinely terrible — servers earn $10/hr base wage and depend on tips. For large groups (6+), many restaurants add an automatic 18-20% gratuity.